Cookies CK does not stop Google Tag Manager cookies
3 years 5 months ago - 3 years 5 months ago #61033
by eemeli
Cookies CK does not stop Google Tag Manager cookies was created by eemeli
Hello!
I am testing your Cookies CK plugin on a website. It seems to block all other cookies (there are not many), but _ga and _gid are loaded always - even before the visitor has given or declined consent.
If the visitor declines all cookies, _ga and _gid are still stored. Both of these cookies were found by the plugin scanner and they have been added to the Analytics category automatically. Yet still, it does not work.
I have also blocked all iframes in the settings. That doesn't help.
These _ga and _gid cookies are loaded by Google Tag Manager. If I remove the Tag Manager script from the page, these cookies are not saved. Why does Cookies CK ignore the cookies saved by Tag Manager?
I know this is a free plugin and I don't expect much, but any feedback would be helpful. Thank you very much, merci!
I am testing your Cookies CK plugin on a website. It seems to block all other cookies (there are not many), but _ga and _gid are loaded always - even before the visitor has given or declined consent.
If the visitor declines all cookies, _ga and _gid are still stored. Both of these cookies were found by the plugin scanner and they have been added to the Analytics category automatically. Yet still, it does not work.
I have also blocked all iframes in the settings. That doesn't help.
These _ga and _gid cookies are loaded by Google Tag Manager. If I remove the Tag Manager script from the page, these cookies are not saved. Why does Cookies CK ignore the cookies saved by Tag Manager?
I know this is a free plugin and I don't expect much, but any feedback would be helpful. Thank you very much, merci!
Last edit: 3 years 5 months ago by eemeli.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
3 years 5 months ago #61035
by ced1870
Joomlack Webmaster and Developer
Replied by ced1870 on topic Cookies CK does not stop Google Tag Manager cookies
Hi
no matter if the plugin is free, it shall work correctly
please give me your url, because on my tests it works
CEd
no matter if the plugin is free, it shall work correctly
please give me your url, because on my tests it works
CEd
Joomlack Webmaster and Developer
The following user(s) said Thank You: eemeli
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
3 years 5 months ago - 3 years 5 months ago #61040
by eemeli
Replied by eemeli on topic Cookies CK does not stop Google Tag Manager cookies
Thank you for your reply!
When I mentioned a free plugin I didn't mean that I don't expect the plugin to work. I meant that I don't expect any support for possible issues.
The domain is
Thank you very much for checking it!
When I mentioned a free plugin I didn't mean that I don't expect the plugin to work. I meant that I don't expect any support for possible issues.
The domain is
This message contains confidential information
. I have turned the plugin on now, but I cannot keep it on too long because the analytics cookies keep appearing. It is a website of a lawyer company, and they don't want anyone to notice that cookies are saved even if there is no consent. Thank you very much for checking it!
Last edit: 3 years 5 months ago by eemeli.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
3 years 5 months ago #61042
by ced1870
Joomlack Webmaster and Developer
Replied by ced1870 on topic Cookies CK does not stop Google Tag Manager cookies
just tested by my side on Chrome and Firefox, it works, no cookie at all is stored before you accept
may be that there is still a cookie that was previously stored. HAve you cleared all your cookies before testing ?
may be that there is still a cookie that was previously stored. HAve you cleared all your cookies before testing ?
Joomlack Webmaster and Developer
The following user(s) said Thank You: eemeli
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
3 years 5 months ago #61043
by eemeli
Replied by eemeli on topic Cookies CK does not stop Google Tag Manager cookies
Hello! Thank you for checking. Yes, I always erase all cookies before testing.
I made you a very short video of how it looks like on my computer, here:
During the video, I noticed that even though the _ga and _gid cookies appear, their content is empty.
So maybe I have misunderstood the whole thing and thought that those cookies should not exist at all, while actually they just need to be empty for it to work.
Probably that is the case. If the empty content is enough - I suppose it is - then the plugin probably works as it should.
I made you a very short video of how it looks like on my computer, here:
This message contains confidential information
During the video, I noticed that even though the _ga and _gid cookies appear, their content is empty.
So maybe I have misunderstood the whole thing and thought that those cookies should not exist at all, while actually they just need to be empty for it to work.
Probably that is the case. If the empty content is enough - I suppose it is - then the plugin probably works as it should.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
3 years 5 months ago #61048
by eemeli
Replied by eemeli on topic Cookies CK does not stop Google Tag Manager cookies
Ah, seems like I accidentally posted the Vimeo managing link instead of the hidden video link.
No need to watch it in case there is no issue with empty _ga and _gid cookies. If they are supposed to be there as empty, it is ok. If they should not be there, then you might want to check out the video.
Anyway, thank you for your time!
This message contains confidential information
No need to watch it in case there is no issue with empty _ga and _gid cookies. If they are supposed to be there as empty, it is ok. If they should not be there, then you might want to check out the video.
Anyway, thank you for your time!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.248 seconds